Hizbullah Precedent II – Demilitarization Arrangements

Point of View No. 41

Israel may not settle only for a cease fire and new security mechanism on the Lebanese side of the border, but may also demand a demilitarization arrangement that would prevent Hizbullah from renewing its military ability (Benn and Harel, Ha'aretz, 7/18/06). The Re'ut Institute contends that such an arrangement on the Lebanese border may serve as a precedent for future security arrangements in Gaza and the West Bank.

What is the Issue?​

Demilitarization in Lebanon​

  • According to statements made by Israeli Prime Minister and Minister of Defense, Israel's initial goal in the current conflict was to remove Hizbullah away from its northern border.

  • Over the past couple of days an additional demand has been mentioned to demilitarize Hizbullah in order to prevent it from stocking strategic weapons such as rockets and missiles. Currently, the arrangements discussed do not rely on an Israeli-Lebanese agreement and do not require reciprocity on Israel's side.​​

Demilitarization in Gaza and the West Bank​

  • The idea of a demilitarized Palestinian entity accompanied by monitoring mechanisms (hereinafter: "Demilitarization Principle") is one of the mainstays of Israel's policy vis-à-vis the Palestinians.​

  • The demilitarization principle has so far been manifested in the security arrangements provided by the Interim Agreement (9/95) and enforced through Israel's control over the external perimeter. Israel has expected that within the framework of the Permanent Status Agreement, the Palestinians will officially accept the demilitarization principle.

  • The demilitarization principle has been eroded to the point of collapse following Israel's withdrawal from the border between Gaza and Egypt (11/05) and Hamas' electoral victory. The combination between Israel's insistence on the Roadmap and the Palestinians' fundamental objection to the establishment of a Palestinian State with Provisional Borders, has further eroded the principle (see: Militarized Palestinian State)

Hizbullah Precedent II – Demilitarization Arrangements
קראו את הגרסה בעברית
Tags

Two State Solution, Diaspora Relations, Delegitimization, Partner for Peace, Emergency Preparedness

2006-04-01

Point of View

National Security

Regional Security

It appears that there would be a need for an arrangement that would assure the absence of "strategic weapons" in Lebanon and establish international mechanisms of enforcement and monitoring.

Related Content

First Quarterly Report - mapping the Jewish Peoplehood field in Israel

First Quarterly Report - mapping the Jewish Peoplehood field in Israel

We are very proud to present the first quarterly report of the Jewish People Field Mapping System. The report presents data for the first quarter of 2022 (January-March) and further completion of April information. This is the first report produced on the basis of the new mapping system.

We are Hiring!

We are Hiring!

Call for Applicants for Analyst Position at the Reut Institute
DEADLINE FOR SUBMISSION: SUNDAY, MAY 1ST BY 09:30 AM
About

The Red Green Alliance is Coming to America

The Red Green Alliance is Coming to America

The Impact of the Islamo-Leftist Coalition on US Jewry & Foreign Policy, & Israel's National Security